Couldn’t choose so I got them both!
After seeing reviews for the L’oreal La Nude palettes, I was bummed that I hadn’t seen them yet in any of my local drugstores. While I was in Toronto I happened to pop into a Shoppers Drug Mart and when I saw the La Nude palettes 1 and 2 I was so excited I grabbed them both. I had high hopes for these after being really impressed with the Maybelline The Nudes palette (see review).
The La Nudes 1 has your typical brown and taupe type of neutral shades that I think has a nice mix of both cool and warm tones, vs some palettes which tend to lean one way or the other. It has 4/10 matte shades.
La Nude 1 – brown and taupe neutrals
La Nudes 2 is more of a pink and plum toned palette. It has 6/10 matte shades.
La Nude 2 – more pinks and plums
Here are the swatches of the La Nude 1 VS La Nude 2:
La Nude 1
La Nude 2
Sadly, I can’t do a positive review of these palettes. I found the quality of these shadows just isn’t there for me. Here were my main issues:
Major fall-out: The La Nude 1 had the most fall-out. It was a mess trying to apply them and I would have to do a ton of clean-up under my eyes with a cotton bud. I did think the La Nude 2 had less fall-out.
Dude, where’s my eye shadow? When I tried to blend these shadows, they would nearly disappear and I would have to go back and reapply them to try to build the intensity back up (who has the time?).
Creasing & fading: Most of the shades from the La Nude 1 creased on me – with primer. The La Nude 2 shades didn’t crease, but both palettes would fade on me throughout the day.
Too expensive! In Canada, the La Nude palettes are a whopping $29.99 CAD. By comparison, Maybelline The Nudes palette is only $14.99 CAD and you get 12 neutral shadows (vs only 10 in the L’oreal palettes). I would skip the L’oreal and get the Maybelline or some of the new NYX shadows which are awesome (see review) instead.
I think I could have been less critical of the La Nudes if it wasn’t for the price. I expected better quality from a $30 palette. I have so many other shadows that I like way more. The L’oreal La Nudes were a miss for me.
Thanks for reading!
Love,
Nerdy Librarian Girl ❤
Pingback: Maybelline The Blushed Nudes Palette | nerdylibrariangirl
I like the plum palette – but yes, they seem expensive for the quality you get!
LikeLike
The plum palette was the better of the two and the shades are really pretty – just too much work for that price point.
LikeLike
That’s too bad! Thanks for the review in them though!
LikeLike
I stalked the displays of these for weeks before they were released and then I was totally shocked at how expensive they were when they finally came out! Come on loreal, you’re still a drugstore brand.
Bummer that the quality and colors didn’t end up matching the price tag though.
LikeLike
Your instinct was right to skip them. Definitely too expensive.
LikeLike
It’s so sad though, it was so exciting to have more palettes at the drugstore!
LikeLike
I’ve read mixed reviews of these palettes – but it does boil down to how expensive these are! $30 for a drugstore palette and the case isn’t even that nice. L’Oreal does tend to be on the expensive side typically. I’ve never been all that impressed with L’Oreal eye shadows – I find them dry and difficult to blend. Maybelline, CoverGirl and even Rimmel eye shadows perform better in my opinion! Great review and thanks for swatching all the colours!
LikeLike
Thanks! You’re right about the packaging – the case is plain plastic and, because they don’t come in a box, mine were scratched. And I forgot to mention one was missing its applicator, although I don’t usually use the little sponge-tipped ones that come with drugstore palettes.
LikeLiked by 1 person
God I didn’t realize how much more it was for you all. It’s a shame you didn’t like them for all the money you spent!! I personally love them but I always like seeing how other people feel about the products I love
LikeLike
Sometimes I wonder if the same makeup product sold in different countries is actually manufactured differently, like in a different factory? It might explain why sometimes a product being raved about by US or UK bloggers is sometimes a bust when I try the Canadian version. I know the packaging, shade range, and shade names can often be different, so maybe the formulas can differ too?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hmmmmm I wonder if that’s the case!! That would make a lot of sense actually
LikeLiked by 1 person
I really like the first one but I wouldn’t want to pay that much for them!!
LikeLike
I know right? I actually didn’t know the price before I bought them. It was quite a shock at the check-out.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Great review! I was wondering about that pallette…….
LikeLike
Thank-you! I think, if you’re like most make-up loving bloggers, you likely have lots of other palettes that perform much better.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It’s so weird for me seeing what drugstore palettes cost in other countries. That’s way too expensive for the quality of that product
LikeLiked by 1 person
I think we pay a lot more for make-up and other beauty products in Canada. I love getting to visit the U.S. and go to shops like Ulta. You guys are so lucky! 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
I know. Having met so many bloggers from around the world, I’m just beginning to see how good the US has it in terms of beauty deals
LikeLike
Great honest review. I like the subtitles like dude where’s my eyeshadow? Lol
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank-you! 🙂
LikeLike