Almay Smart Shade Butter Kiss Lipsticks VS Revlon Lip Butters

Almay Smart Shade Butter Kiss Lipsticks

Almay Smart Shade Butter Kiss Lipsticks

A friend of mine was wearing the prettiest pinky-berry lip and when I asked her what it was, she pulled out one of the new Almay Smart Shade Butter Kiss lipsticks. We had previously bonded over our love of the Revlon Lip Butters, so I asked her if she liked the Almay as much as the Revlon, and she said yes! Then I knew I had to try them.

The Butter Kiss lipsticks are “ultra-hydrating buttery lip color” available in “12 shades expertly coordinated to your unique skintone.” You are meant to pick your skintone (light, light/medium, or medium) and then pick one of the four shades in that group – berry, pink, nude, or red. I, like most people, just swatched them all and picked out the ones I liked best. I really liked Berry-Medium (which was the one my friend was wearing) and Red-Medium, the darkest shade of the 12.

Almay Smart Shade Butter Kiss Lipsticks Berry-Medium and Red-Medium

Berry-Medium and Red-Medium

Almay Smart Shade Butter Kiss Lipsticks Berry-Medium and Red-Medium

Left: Berry-Medium Right: Red-Medium

Berry-Medium is a cool-toned, berry pink with some purple undertones going on. Red-Medium is a brown-based red.

Swatches Almay Smart Shade Butter Kiss Lipsticks Berry-Medium and Red-Medium

Left: Berry-Medium Right: Red-Medium

The packaging looks extremely similar to the Revlon Lip Butters (they even both have “butter” in the name) so a comparison between the two is inevitable.

Almay Butter Kiss VS Revlon Lip Butter

Battle of the Lip Butters!

I immediately noticed that the Butter Kiss lipsticks smell very similar to the Lip Butters; a light, slightly sweet, slightly vanilla scent. I don’t find the Revlon ones have any taste, but the Almay do.

Berry-Medium and Red-Medium are not dupes for any of the 8 Revlon Lip Butters I own. While I was swatching them, I noticed the Lip Butters are more pigmented than the Almay and the Almay are a little more sheer. Both are very hydrating.

I would say one difference for me is that the Almay are much longer-wearing and are also a lip stain. I don’t find the Revlon Lip Butters stain my lips at all. If you didn’t like the Lip Butters because of the staying power, you might like the Almay ones better. Both shades I tried left a very flattering stain that was pretty much exactly the same colour as the lipstick (not like the awful staining I experienced with the CoverGirl LipPerfection).

I really like these! I definitely like them as much as the Lip Butters and I think the shade range is quite different from Revlon. At my drugstore, they were the exact same price too – $9.99 CAD.

Have you tried the Almay Butter Kiss lipsticks?

Thanks for reading!
Love,
NerdyLibrarianGirl

Advertisements

8 Comments

Filed under Lips, Lipstick, Reviews

8 responses to “Almay Smart Shade Butter Kiss Lipsticks VS Revlon Lip Butters

  1. Pingback: Hanh's "I'm Wide Awake it's Morning" makeup (almay smart shade)

  2. V

    Haha–with all of Almay’s line in which you are supposed to pick out your skin tone, eye color, etc., I end up picking the one I like best anyway

    Like

  3. karenmillerthekiller

    I LOVE these, one of my favorite drugstore lip products!

    Like

  4. Conspiracy theory time! Revlon owns Almay… Perhaps this is a slight modification of the Revlon lip butters and they slapped on the Almay name?
    At the very least, I hope the shade range for Almay differs from the Revlon so the selection of lip butters is expanded! (I like the shade Red-Medium)

    Like

I'd love to hear what you think! Please leave me a comment.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s